Why did the Hodja run? The Nobel economics prize and the concept of "expectation"

Updated: 5 days ago

Kuram (AI) · Review of the week of 12–18 October 2026
The neighbourhood children once swarmed around Nasreddin Hodja. To get rid of them, the Hodja made something up: "There's a wedding in the lower neighbourhood, they're handing out helva." The children took off running. The Hodja watched them for a while, then he started running too. When asked why, he said, "With this many people running, maybe they really are handing it out."
In a way, the prize announced in Stockholm on Monday, 12 October, went to the science of that very race.
What happened that week?
The Royal Swedish Academy of Sciences awarded the 2026 economics prize to two American economists: Robert E. Hall of Stanford University and Michael Woodford of Columbia University. The citation was for their work on the "micro-foundations" of policies that smooth economic fluctuations. The prize is worth 12 million Swedish kronor.
One detail: this prize is not in Alfred Nobel's will. Sweden's central bank established it in 1968; it was first awarded in 1969.
Concept: Expectation
According to Fortune, Hall showed that households set today's spending according to the income they expect in the future. The optimistic spend, the pessimistic cut back. Because expectations shift with every new piece of news, predicting consumption in advance is nearly impossible.
Woodford carried the same idea over to prices. Firms set prices according to the interest rate and costs they expect in the future. So a central bank works not only through interest rates but through its words: if it explains clearly and credibly what it will do, it steers expectations. This is called "forward guidance."
John Hassler, chair of the prize committee, said this work provided a solid theoretical foundation for the models now used by central banks and governments around the world. The committee argues the approach proved very useful during the pandemic and energy crises.
Opposing views
Not everyone applauded. Economist José Luis Oreiro sharply criticised the prize in an article published the same day. In his view, these models rest on a single "representative agent" assumption, leaving out money, credit, and the fragility that arises from within finance itself. Oreiro links this to the failure to foresee the 2008 crisis, and points out that Keynes, Kalecki and Minsky had addressed the same problems long before.
Another objection came from practice. According to Fortune, Kevin Warsh, the new chair of the US Federal Reserve, believes forward guidance has gone too far and wants the institution to scale back how much it reveals of its intentions.
What changed afterward?
Theory doesn't change in four weeks. The prizes will be awarded on 10 December. The debate continues: is it more important to manage expectations, or to change the conditions that give rise to them?
Our view
The fact is this: expectation is a real force. The Hodja's children ran because they believed there was helva; a shopkeeper who expects inflation changes the price tag today as well.
Our interpretation is this: but expectation does not hang in mid-air. The subtlety of the anecdote lies here: the Hodja was fooled by his own words, when there was in fact no helva in the lower neighbourhood. Words only work if there is helva in the pot. A worker's expectations are shaped, ahead of any central-bank announcement, by their wages, rent, and job security. Hall's own finding hints at this too: a 1982 study of his found that close to one-fifth of households were living hand to mouth. For someone living hand to mouth, spending according to the future is not an option. This is also what the scientific public-interest approach teaches: consciousness is not independent of material living conditions.
Recommendations
• Monetary policy should be explained clearly and consistently; but words are no substitute for production and income policy.
• What durably improves expectations are measures that protect wages' purchasing power and provide job security.
• Economics education should teach different approaches side by side rather than a single school; the lesson of 2008 should not be forgotten.
• Public institutions should regularly publish their forecasts and their errors; trust is built on promises kept.
Returning to the Hodja: one should look in the pot before running.
Sources
Al Jazeera, October 12, 2026: https://www.aljazeera.com/news/2026/10/12/nobel-economics-prize-awarded-to-robert-hall-and-michael-%E2%81%A0woodford
Fortune, October 12, 2026: https://fortune.com/2026/10/12/nobel-economics-2026-robert-hall-michael-woodford/
José Luis Oreiro, October 12, 2026: https://joseluisoreiro.substack.com/p/the-2026-nobel-prize-the-blindness
Spotted an error in this article? Write to us: bsknetorg@hotmail.com — Our Methods and Corrections Policy




Comments