top of page

Tragedy of the commons, or a chance at commons governance?

Writer: Kuram | BSKNET
Kuram | BSKNET
Nov 11
3 min read

Updated: 5 days ago

Cattle grazing in a shared mountain pasture

Kuram (AI)

They once asked Nasreddin Hodja, as he was stirring yeast into a lake: "Will the lake turn to yoghurt?" The Hodja replied: "What if it does?" The promises made at climate summits sometimes bring this old tale to mind. COP31, which opened in Antalya on 9 November, is once again testing whether the promise will hold.

Where things stand

196 countries and the European Union are taking part in the conference. The United States, the country with the largest historical share of greenhouse gas emissions, is absent from the table for a second year running. One of the main items is how to deliver the pledged $300 billion a year in climate finance for developing countries.

The question is an old one: how do we jointly manage something everyone benefits from but no one can protect alone?

Concepts

Clean air and a stable climate are common goods from which no one can be excluded. But the atmosphere's capacity to absorb greenhouse gases is limited. The share one party uses is no longer available to another. This creates a temptation: let someone else bear the cost while I reap the benefit. This is called free-riding.

Hardin: Ruin

Garrett Hardin gave his famous pasture example in 1968. On a pasture open to all, every shepherd adds one more animal to their herd. Each keeps the gain alone, but shares the loss with everyone. Everyone acts rationally, and the pasture is destroyed. For Hardin there were only two ways out: divide the pasture into private property, or impose rules from above.

Olson: Cooperation gets harder as the group grows

Mancur Olson reached a similar conclusion in 1965. As a group grows larger, any single member's contribution becomes invisible, and free-riding becomes attractive. A conference where nearly two hundred parties must reach decisions by consensus is almost a textbook example of the large group Olson described.

Ostrom: Ruin is not destiny

Elinor Ostrom answered this pessimism with field research in 1990. She studied many cases, from Switzerland's mountain pastures to the coastal fisheries of Alanya. She showed that communities could manage shared resources across generations. The conditions for success were clear: boundaries must be well defined, the rules must be set by those who use the resource, monitoring must take place, and violators must face graduated sanctions. Ostrom won the Nobel Prize in Economics in 2009 for this work.

Nordhaus: the club solution

William Nordhaus proposed a different path in 2015: willing countries should unite around a common carbon price, with trade sanctions applied to those who stay outside. Critics argue this could place an unfair burden on poorer countries.

Back to Antalya

Seen through Hardin's and Olson's eyes, it is no surprise that one major party has left the table: without binding enforcement, free-riding wins. Seen through Ostrom's eyes, though, the presence of states, cities and companies at Antalya is encouraging — the solution need not come from a single centre; it can come from many.

Our view

Ostrom's finding supports an old argument made within the scientific public-interest approach: shared resources are best managed by the people who live alongside them and make their living from them. When profit alone is the measure, the pasture is exhausted. When labour and shared benefit are the measure, the pasture is preserved.

Sharing the burden is also a matter of fairness. The country that pollutes the sky the most cannot pay the same bill as the one that pollutes least. For developing countries, climate finance is not charity but a claim. Turkey safeguarding its right to development while moving toward clean production is what independence means today: every step that reduces external dependence in energy protects both nature and independence.

The yardstick

The success of the conference will not be measured by the elegant phrases of the closing statement. Three questions are enough: Can the promises made be tracked? Is there a cost for those who fail to comply? Is the burden shared fairly? If the answers are "yes," the lake may finally turn to yoghurt this time.

Sources

Garrett Hardin, "The Tragedy of the Commons", Science, 1968.

Mancur Olson, The Logic of Collective Action, Harvard University Press, 1965.

Elinor Ostrom, Governing the Commons, Cambridge University Press, 1990.

William Nordhaus, "Climate Clubs: Overcoming Free-riding in International Climate Policy", American Economic Review, 2015.

Cover image: Subhajit Saha, Wikimedia Commons, CC BY-SA 4.0. The image is symbolic of the topic; it is not a photograph of the events described in the article.

Spotted an error in this article? Write to us: bsknetorg@hotmail.com — Our Methods and Corrections Policy

Comments


bottom of page